Claudius Boatman’s Family

With very little documentation available, and relying mainly on published genealogies and local histories, we’re able to piece together a view of the Boatman family. We must rely upon mostly second hand information: the work of genealogists and historians long passed as well as tales and oral tradition. Much of what we know about the family depends on the accuracy of this material; the few actual records found of the Boatman family have, in some cases upheld tradition, and at other times have cast doubt.

One can’t understand the life and times of Claudius Boatman without at least a good working knowledge of his wives and children, as well as stories and records they’ve left behind. Since this is Claudius’ history, here is a brief sketch of his wives and children, the rest left to the many genealogists who have done so much work on their individual ancestors.

Note: I have started to expand the histories of Claudius’ family. I cannot claim to have a fraction of the knowledge that family historians, many who have been studying their individual ancestors for years and even decades, have gathered. If there is any one who wishes to write the history for their ancestor, please comment or email me. If you have anything to add, stories or documentation, please let me know! The linked names, below, contain more information on the individuals. The others are yet to come.

Marie Boatman, wife – born about 1732, died 16 August 1782

The first wife of Claudius Boatman, and the mother of most of his children except William and Nancy, Marie’s last name is often said to be Reed or Reid, although this is sometimes contested by those who believe Marie Reed was the wife of Claudius Jr. Probably born around 1732, it’s most likely she was French or of French descent, and not English. It’s said Marie died in the John Lee Massacre near Winfield, Pennsylvania on August 16th 1782, and is thought to be buried on the site.

Margaret Boatman, daughter – born about 1752, died about 1786

Margaret was born around 1752 and passed away about 1786; the family was in New Rochelle by 1755, which makes Margaret’s birth location uncertain.  She married John Morrison, and is said to have been the mother of at least three children: Marcy (Marcia), John and Samuel, and possibly a Nancy, Zalen, Anna and others. The dates most usually given in published genealogies for the birth of Margaret’s children predate the Boatman family’s entry into Pennsylvania; perhaps Margaret was married more than once.

Fanny “Francoise” Boatman, daughter – born about 1755, died bet 1844 – 47

Fanny was born around 1755, most likely in New Rochelle, Westchester, New York, as that is where the Boatman family was living at the time. Some say her birth was in France or even more improbably, Pennsylvania, and a record of her baptism is said to be at the “English” church in New Rochelle. Possibly married more than once, she married John English, Sr, around the close of the Revolution. During the early years of their marriage, the young family moved from the Island where John lived on the West Branch to the one they subsequently bought opposite Jersey Shore on Pine Creek, now in Cummings township.

Meginness, in his history of Lycoming county, has this to say about the young English family: “The country was extremely wild at that time and it required some nerve to settle in what was in every respect a “howling wilderness.” The Seneca Indians, whose country was less than a hundred miles north, frequently came here to hunt and fish, and parties of them passed his cabin almost daily. John English and his wife Fannie reared a large family. Their son Claudius was the first child born on this part of the creek…” Meginness, elsewhere, gives the name of the Indian as Shawney John.

John and Fanny are said to have had 11 children. Fanny is said to have been laid to rest, next to John, on English Island. The date of her death is unknown, but is said to have been between 1844 and 1847.

Mary (Polly) Boatman, daughter – born 1757, died about 1853

Mary or “Polly” Boatman was probably born about 1757 in New Rochelle, where the Boatman family lived at the time. She married Comfort Wanzer, most likely in Warwick, New York, and they were the parents of one known child, Elizabeth, probably born in Warwick, New York around 1776. Reports of Mary’s early demise are unfounded, as Mary is one of the two children of Claudius with a documented birth date and location. Mary passed away, most likely in Kinzua, Pennsylvania about 1853. Mary is said to be buried in Waterville with her husband, Comfort, in a small, unmarked cemetery.

Claudius Boatman, Jr., son – born about 1759

Claudius Boatman, Jr., is said to have been born about 1759, which places his birth location in New Rochelle, New York. Very little is actually known about Claudius; he served with his father in the Revolution under Captain Thomas Robinson, with Robinson’s Rangers. It’s been reported he was married to Marie Reed, although some controversy remains to this day, some believing Marie Reed was the wife of the Senior Claudius. Claudius is said to have had one child, Robert, born about 1781 and dying in 1782, and possibly another.

Claudius is said to have died from an Indian arrow to the back, and his father settled his estate. It’s unknown where Claudius was buried, but perhaps in the same small cemetery as Comfort and Claudius’ sister, Mary Boatman Wanzer.

Cornelius Boatman, son? – born before 1765, died after 1785

Said to have been a son of Claudius, there is doubt that Cornelius actually existed; many assume the only records found of him are, in fact, mistakes. Very little is known of Cornelius; one record in the Pennsylvania archives shows his name and the name Claudius Boatman is typed above his.

Jane Boatman, daughter – born 1761, died 13 June 1848

Jane is said to have been born in April 1761, which places her birth in New York, although during the time period between the last records of the Boatman family in New Rochelle and the first record of them in the Warwick area. Often it is stated she was born in Pennsylvania which is highly improbable. Jane married James English, a brother of John, and they had about eight children, John, Mary, Esther, Elizabeth, Jane, Sarah and James, and possibly Robert.

From the History of Lycoming county: “James, the younger brother of John English, settled about three miles up Little Pine creek in 1809 and made some improvements, for which he obtained a warrant for 219 acres and eighty-five perches June 10, 1816, and on the 20th of the following August it was surveyed to him. James English and wife spent their lives here and reared a large family. He was a man noted for his integrity and exemplary habits, and did much during his life time to advance the interests of his locality. He built a grist and two saw mills, the ruins of which may still be seen. He died in 1855.”

Jane is said to have about 1848, and is  buried next to James in Bluestone cemetery, Lycoming County; James has a headstone there, but there is none for Jane.

Rebecca Boatman, daughter – born about 1766, died about 1839

Rebecca, was born in about 1766, which places her birth solidly in the Warwick, New York area. She’s said to have died around 1839 in Cummings township, Lycoming, Pennsylvania, although her death may have been much earlier. Rebecca married Isaac Smee and is believed to have had five children, and rumor indicates there was perhaps one more, from a Seneca Brave. Isaac died in 1839 in Cummings township as documented in his Revolutionary Pension papers.

Rebecca is known for having survived an Indian attack, with conflicting information in several local histories. From Meginness’ History of Lycoming, “He (Claudius Boatman) came from Buffalo valley, where, it will be remembered, his daughter Rebecca was scalped by the Indians while making one of their last  forays. She was found and cared for, and recovered. In after years she married Isaac Smee and had three sons, Charles, John, and Alpheus, and two daughters; Mary married Louis Hostrander; Elizabeth, John Shaner. Their mother lived to a good age, but never had any hair on her head after being scalped.”

James Boatman, son – born 1768, died 2 May 1853

James was born about 1768 in New Jersey, possibly very close to the Warwick area. He married Anna Mills and had a family of 12 children. James was on the 1850 census in Butler County, Ohio so his birth year and location are documented; stories of a birth in Pennsylvania or an earlier demise are simply unfounded. The middle name often attributed to James as “hunter” likely comes from the 1800 taxables list in Lycoming county that gives James’ occupation as a hunter. James passed away on May 2nd, 1853 in Butler county, Ohio.

Excerpts from the History and Biographical Cyclopaedia of Butler County, Ohio:

The BOATMANs were one of the earliest families in the county. Jeremiah W. BOATMAN, now living in this township, is a descendant of this family. He was born in Hamilton, (Butler Co., OH), Sep 7, 1840, & is the s/o Mark M. BOATMAN & Cynthia WARWICK. The great-great-grandfather BOATMAN was of French descent, enlisting as a soldier under LAFAYETTE, & taking part in many of the actions of the Revolutionary War. He remained in America at the close of the war where he had married & raised a small family, of which the members were nearly all massacred by the Indians in PA. James BOATMAN was born in Northumberland Co., PA about 1771, as nearly as can be told. On the 22nd of Aug 1799, he married Anna MILLS, dau/o Col. James MILLS, & emigrated to OH two years after. Col. MILLS was of Irish descent. He emigrated from Berks Co., PA, & settled in Hamilton. He had seven children: Reed, Mark, James, Anna, Abbie, Julia, & Eliza. When the colonel started from the East he had three fine-blooded horses. These he sent on in advance, in charge of a man who was going that way, but when he arrived, either owing to the Indians or to the duplicity of his agent, he found neither horses nor man, & was obliged to content himself with his loss. Col. MILLS came down by boat, as did Mr. BOATMAN, who carried his family in a canoe, landing in Cincinnati, where there were then only a few cabins. From there he went to Hamilton. It was at that time a common thing to mark a road by little sticks & stones, to indicate the route; they followed these for a long time, & then discovered that some person had maliciously changed the little end, which indicated the right way, so as to point out another & entirely wrong direction. This cost them several days’ lost labor. As soon as the land was surveyed on the west side of the river, he located 160 acres four miles north of Hamilton, on Four-Mile Creek. Here he built a small cabin, in which he lived until he became easy in money matters, when he erected a commodious frame house, which is still standing. At the time he took up his settlement here there were only three families in his neighborhood–one opposite the FLENNER Mills, one on the farm now owned by Andrew FLENNER, & one on William BROOKS’s present farm. The two former lived in block-houses.

BOATMAN (Hanover Twp., p. 447)
James BOATMAN resided on his farm till his death, at which time he was 80 years old. He reared a family of 13 children: Claudius, James M., Mark M., Sarah M., Mary A., Ann, Jane, Reed M., William, John M., Nathan C., & Jeremiah N., eight boys & 5 girls. Himself, wife, brothers, & sisters were great hunters. In PA they would go out hunting many miles from home & remain for weeks. The game was bears, raccoons, deer, & turkeys, besides small fry. They were often chased by the Indians, having many narrow escapes. On one occasion, while he & his sister were hunting, they were pursued by Indians, & his sister was caught, scalped, & left for dead. She escaped, recovered, & afterwards married & lived to a good old age, although without a forelock, which was artificially supplied. Being penniless at the time of his marriage, he and his wife apprenticed themselves to a farmer for one year to get the means necessary for housekeeping. His wife, besides faithfully attending to her household duties & enduring the hardships of frontier life, acted as an herb physician, in which she was very successful. She was fine horsewoman & a good marksman. One night they had a visitor. The meat was out, & there was no way of getting any more except by shooting it. So she rose early in the morning, built a fire, put on the pot, & went out. Guided by her knowledge of the habits of deer, she soon found one, brought her rifle to her shoulder, & fired. The animal fell, & she soon had a large piece of it in the pot. Her breakfast was soon got ready, & by the time the family was awake & dressed it was upon the table.

Sarah Boatman, daughter – born about 1770, died 1836

Sarah’s birth of about 1770 occurred while the Boatman family lived in the Warwick area of New York. She married John Morrison, and had a family of eight children, Anna Marie, Sarah, Mercy, George, Rachel, Elizabeth, Margaret, Jane and Caroline.  Sarah died about 1836, and her husband, John, in 1837, both on Pine Creek in Brown township, Lycoming County.

Esther Boatman, wife – born before 1765, died after 1810

Claudius married a second time to Esther, probably in 1783 and near Derr’s landing. Some say Esther’s last name is Callahan. Esther was noted as being a Physician and Nurse, self taught from having observed the Indians, a large woman riding a spotted horse to minister to the ill. Esther died sometime after 1810, although little is known of her death and burial. Esther is said to be the mother of William, born 1787, the first white child born in what is now McHenry township in Lycoming, and possibly another child, Nancy.

Nancy Boatman, daughter – birth, death unknown

Very little is known of Nancy Boatman, who filed a pension application as Claudius Boatman’s heir and daughter. A letter replying to her request indicates there is no pension available for adult children. The statements made by Nancy on the application are believed by many to be somewhat erroneous. Some family histories indicate Nancy Boatman married William Neville. There is some doubt that Nancy was actually a daughter of Claudius and Esther, perhaps she was a daughter of Claudius, Jr.  Spencer Kraybll, listed her in his “Pennsylvania’s Pine Creek Valley and Pioneer Families.” I would suspect that the “Neville” would be one of the Nevil/Nabel/Nable families that settled along Pine Creek.

William Boatman, son – born 6 Mar 1787, died 3 March 1849

William Boatman was born in 1787 in what is now McHenry Township, Lycoming county, Pennsylvania, the first white child born in the area. He married “Nancy” Agnes Cole and had 11 children, Claudius, John, Jane, William, Thomas, Mary, Margaret, Cornelius, Robert, Sarah and Caroline.

William is buried in Lower English Center/Calahan Cemetery, d. Mar 3, 1849 “aged 62 yr.” with wife, Nancy:  d. Apr 12, 1868 “aged 80 yr.” “Wife of Wm.” Two of his children are buried there as well.

I’ve had a lot of fun researching Claudius, and am pleased to share everything I’ve learned, much of it due to other researchers before me – please feel free to use anything on this site – I do ask you to source it, though, so others may find it.  And please, share what you know in the same spirit this has been shared.  mvkirby – I can be emailed directly at

Although I’ve personally done some research on several of Claudius’ children, it has not been to the extent that I’ve researched Claudius or my own branch; I’ve relied heavily on the trees of others. Discussion is encouraged! I do want to be as accurate as possible.


13 thoughts on “Claudius Boatman’s Family

  1. James served in the military, but not in the Rev. War. He would have only been 15 at the end of the war. Yes, he may have been a drummer or something else, but he would not have been an Ensign

  2. From above: “The Old Pine Creek cemetery was read in 2003, and there was apparently no readable headstone for Margaret or John. -ii”

    I have readings from the Old Pine Creek cemetery that was taken by Fort Antes chapter of DAR dated August 1914 and published in the Jersey Shore Herald. There is no information regarding Margaret or John.

    • Thanks, David! Good to know – I don’t have any reason to not believe they are buried there – at least we know if the stones were deteriorated to nothing it happened before 1914.

  3. In the 1790 census, William Morrison and his wife, according to Morrison family had married and have only one child born at that time. The William Morrison family is listed with 5 children and the ages and sex match the birth of John and Margaret’s children. It needs further Investigation but, it could be a good lead.

  4. Searching for details on the life of Mary Smee, daughter of Isaac and Rebecca Boatman Smee……….she married Joel Lewis Hostrander and that’s what can be found……… life span details, no listings of children, etc. would certainly appreciate any help. This is for a DAR supplemental which would open other lines connected to Boatman, English, Campbell, Gamble and Tomb.

    • I had a tough time at this myself. From what I have (which might not be much, but it could be something to work with…) I have Louis Hostrander/Ostrander marrying Mary Smee. Together they had Margaret Hostrander/Ostrander, who then married Philip Crider from the Woolrich area (Watch out here though because there were several Crider families with several spelling variations in the Woolrich area, and there were several Phillip Criders.) Philip and Margaret were the parents of Acirema Crider, and she married Robert Stevenson, of the Woolrich Stevensons who came from Ireland. I hope this helps. If anyone finds this to be incorrect, please let me know.

      • Thanks K.! I apologize for not answering sooner! Traveling, Xmas, etc! I know very little of this incredibly tough line, and what I do know came from Dolly, who answered earlier! The census records I’ve been able to verify show exactly the same information you have. 🙂

  5. Hostrander.

    ” In the Jan.1999 DBK,we had an article about member Francis (Buzz) Hostrander of Pine City, NY and a few of his WWII Stories, we asked Buzz to get back to us with the story of how his name got changed to Ostrander..

    He responded with a generous size envelope full of his research over many years supported by photocopies of tomstones, markers, and lists of data. He also sent a reply from the OFA’s one and only genealogist, Emmett Ostrander, that probably was prepared several years ago. It reads as follows:.

    The Hostranders.

    I’m convinced that some of our forefathers went to great lengths to make our genealogical task difficult. Take the case of Jael Ostrander, son of Johannes Ostrander and Elizabeth Terwilliger, born 1768 and baptized the same year at Shawangunk, Ulster Co. NY RDC. Jael quietly married Anatje Smedes ca 1787. Together they had a daughter Sarah, also baptized at Shawangunk, who probably died young..

    Researching Jael and Annatje, even at this early part of their lives was difficult, because the left little information regarding their existence. Quietly and without leaving clues, they relocated to Lycoming Co. Pennsylvania. At that point in time, this part of Pennsylvania was practically void of people but a potentially great area for lumbering. Jael appears in the 1800 Mifflin Township tax rolls using the name Lewis, then in the 1810 Census as Joel. Possible because of the ever-increasing government intervention into private lives like tax rolls and census taking, somehow Ostrander became Hostrander, It could be said tha Jael/Lewis/Joel Ostrander/Hostrander was doing a darn good job of covering his tracks as researchers for a century were unable to determine his lineage..

    Their one mistake was not taking into account the determination of a couple of descendants who together joined forces with the Ostrander Family Association and solved the puzzle to properly place Jael/Annatje in their rightful place with Jael as a direct descendant of our Pieter I, who arrived in New Netherlands in 1660..

    So, we say to Lois(Hostrander)Henderson and husband George and to Francis (Buzz) Hostrander thanks from all of us in the OFA. You deserve the thanks of all Hostranders everywhere.”.

    This article was originally at

    My comments from research:.

    At the time that Jael and Annatje went to (Northumberland) (Lycoming) Co. Pennsylvania. Isaac Smee was married to Rebecca Boatman. .

    Note: Other popular spellings of Smee was Smedes, Smead. Annatje may have very well been related to Isaac Smee and the possible reason for their departure to Pennsylvania..

    Family history shows a Louis Ostrander(ca 1790) married to Mary Smee. They are the parents of three daughters. Only no Louis Ostrander has been found. I have had a few fellow family researchers agree with me on this point. One being Rodea English Ladd. There is no death date for Annatje (Smedes) Ostrander. After Annatje death, Lewis/Jael/Joel Ostrander married Mary Smee. The three girls are Eliza Ostrander age 37 m. Joseph Lupole (1850 census), Sarah Ostrander, age 35 m. James Stewart. Joel Ostrander age 80 is living with James and Sarah and Charity Ostrander m. John Harris living in Kinzua, Warren Co. Pennsylvania in 1850

    Abraham Harris in charge of Isaac Smee’s will. names Joel Ostrander that he is Father in law allthis is on my tree on Is there anything else you need.?

  6. I meant to comment, but thanks, Dolly, for answering. It’s a tough branch, and I went to my tree on ancestry to see what I had (which, by the way, mostly came from Dolly) and got distracted…we’d love to hear back on any progress you may make!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s